Shing v University of the Arts London [2026] EAT 154
Appeal concerning comparators in race discrimination claims
The claimant had been summarily dismissed from his role as a tutor after an inappropriate relationship with a mature student. He brought these proceedings on the grounds of race discrimination arguing that two other non Chinese members of staff (G and H) had been treated differently for similar behaviour. The ET found G and H were neither statutory / direct comparators nor did they assist as “evidential” comparators because their conduct could be differentiated.
John Bowers KC, sitting as a Deputy, dismissed the appeal as (and as set out in his summary)
"where the case for the Chinese claimant was that he had not been treated as leniently as actual comparators G & H, it was open to the ET to decide that the circumstances of both G & H were materially different. It was not necessary for the tribunal to consider a hypothetical comparator which would have been an empty and arid exercise given that the hypothetical comparator would have been the Claimant who was other than Chinese."
He also comments on the decision in Ramphal stating, again in his summary,
"it was not authority that any intervention by HR in advising on a decision to dismiss rendered a dismissal unfair. Indeed it was important that HR helped to maintain consistency between decisions in different parts of an organisation."
Published: 18/11/2026 12:05