Baker v The Governing Body of St Charles RC Primary School [2026] EAT 158

Appeal in unfair dismissal claims where the clamant argued the ET's reasoning was insufficient

The Claimant, the headteacher of a primary school, was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct following allegations of smelling of alcohol at work, poor playground safeguarding, unprofessional conduct (including discussing two colleagues’ alleged relationship) and a breach of confidentiality during her suspension. The ET dismissed her claims of unfair and wrongful dismissal, finding that the respondent had conducted a reasonable investigation, genuinely and reasonably believed the allegations, and acted within the range of reasonable responses. The ET further found that the Claimant’s conduct amounted to gross misconduct justifying her summary dismissal.

In this appeal, the claimant argued that the ET had failed to provide adequate reasons, in particular by not sufficiently engaging with her case that witnesses were inconsistent and had colluded against her, by failing to address alleged deficiencies in the investigation of each allegation, and by failing to give separate and adequate reasons for dismissing the wrongful dismissal claim. Andrew Burns KC, sitting as a Deputy High Court judge, dismissed the appeal as the ET’s reasons, read fairly and as a whole, adequately explained why it had rejected the case and why the respondent had reasonable grounds for its beliefs following a reasonable investigation. The ET was not required to address every evidential contention advanced by the Claimant, provided that it dealt with the principal issues in dispute. The EAT also held that the ET, had properly distinguished between the statutory unfair dismissal test and the contractual test for wrongful dismissal, albeit the reasoning was concise.

https://www.gov.uk/employment-appeal-tribunal-decisions/mrs-v-baker-v-the-governing-body-of-st-charles-rc-primary-school-2026-eat-158

Published: 17/11/2026 11:33

Sign up for free email alerts

Email address
First name
Last name
Receive daily
Receive weekly
I agree to this site's terms and conditions

message