McManus v British Airways plc [2026] EAT 155
Appeal concerning comments by an Occupational Health worker and whether they constituted harassment
The summary below is that set out in the judgment:
When applying section 26(4) Equality Act 2010, in order to decide whether conduct had an effect referred to in section 26(1)(b), the employment tribunal should, in overview, consider two questions: (1) Did the claimant in fact perceive the conduct as having such an effect? (2) If so, is it reasonable to regard the conduct as having such an effect in all the relevant circumstances of the case? What are or are not the relevant circumstances of the case is not prescribed by the statute and is a fact-sensitive question. The EAT will not interfere with the tribunal’s assessment of them unless it treats as relevant, circumstances which no tribunal acting reasonably could so treat, or fails to take into account circumstances which any tribunal acting reasonably would regard as relevant, or its overall evaluation surmounts the high threshold for a true perversity challenge.
In this case the employment tribunal did not err in concluding that a particular comment made by an OH practitioner in the context of an OH assessment meeting was not reasonably to be regarded as having a section 26(1)(b) effect. The claimant’s mental ill health could in law properly be treated as a relevant circumstance, but was not bound to lead to the conclusion that it was reasonable to regard the conduct as having that effect; and, on a fair reading, the tribunal did not err by failing to take it into account. Nor, on a fair reading, did the tribunal err by considering the effect of the particular remark in isolation from the wider context of the overall meeting and other things that were said by the OH practitioner during the course of it. Observations in Harkins v Marks and Spencer plc [2026] EAT 131 considered and followed.
Published: 16/11/2026 11:17